price right, sell quick at Ruggles House, 112 East 19 Street

simple rule (hard to apply?)
You will be excused if you failed to notice that the Manhattan loft #4R at 112 East 19 Street had been on the market, as it was available for 21 days before finding a buyer on December 4. The Board at the venerable Ruggles House must have taken a while to approve the deal (or the paperwork was delayed), as the loft did not close until April 20.

Consistent with this velocity, the clearing price of $1.65mm was a spare 3% off the asking price of $1.7mm.

repeat after me, kids
A well-priced loft sells (relatively) quickly in any market. Signing a contract in 21 days is a sign of a well-priced loft. So is pricing below building comps.

reading between primitive lines
Everything that this listing description does not say screams "primitive":

Wonderful square shaped loft. Three sunny exposures with huge windows facing South East and West. Ceiling height 11’ +/- . Handsome birdseye maple hardwood floors. Enjoy this three bedroom design or bring your architect and make it your own. The Ruggles House is one of the few premier loft coops in Gramercy Park.Excellent co-op in Fabulous Gramercy Park.

Let’s review…. From this (complete) description, we know this is 3 bedrooms, with 11 foot ceilings and maple floors. We can reasonably conclude that the windows are big (pix = consistent with "huge"), and are prepared to believe it is sunny, though we’d need to see to really believe.

Here’s what we can be pretty sure about: neither the kitchen, nor the baths, nor the overall condition is much to brag on. Thus, expectations are set that the place needs an upgrade, at a minimum. Pricing the "1,950 sq ft" loft at $872/ft is another hint.

renovations commend(ed) high prices
It is not surprising that a building with only 24 lofts would not have had a sale since The Peak, but here are the last three sales at Ruggles:

Aug 4, 2008 #11R 1,950 sq ft $3.05mm $1,564/ft new renovation
Mar 24, 2008 #3F 1,800 sq ft $2.075mm $1,153/ft not a lot of bragging
Nov 30, 2007 #2F 1,800 sq ft $2.095mm $1,164/ft reno kitchen, granite + marble baths

Starting #4R at $1.7mm after these on-the-way-to-Peak prices was a concession to the changed marketplace and to the work that any buyer is likely to do. Remember: 21 days to contract at a 3% discount. Props to the seller and to Karen Hartnett of PruDE for getting this on and off The Market in a hurry.

© Sandy Mattingly 2010

 

 

Tagged with: , , , , , , ,

Leave a Reply